Canada will soon enter into negotiations with Iran on reparations for the victims' families
Ashley Burke, Nahayat Tizhoosh · CBC News · Posted: May 20, 2021 3:25 PM ET | Last Updated: May 20
On Jan. 8, 2020, Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps shot down Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 in the skies over Tehran with two surface-to-air missiles, killing all 176 people aboard, including 138 with ties to Canada. (Ebrahim Noroozi/Associated Press)
Ontario's Superior Court of Justice has ruled that the shooting down of Flight PS752 by Iran was an intentional act of terrorism.
The Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) shot down the Ukraine International Airlines flight with two surface-to-air missiles shortly after takeoff in Tehran on Jan. 8, 2020, killing all 176 passengers onboard. There were 138 passengers onboard with ties to Canada, including 55 Canadian citizens and 30 permanent residents.
"The plaintiffs have established that the shooting down of Flight 752 by the defendants was an act of terrorism and constitutes 'terrorist activity'..."Justice Edward Belobaba wrote in his decision issued Thursday.
"I find on a balance of probabilities that the missile attacks on Flight 752 were intentional and directly caused the deaths of all onboard."
Ukraine 'even closer' to decision on legal action over Flight PS752, ambassador says
Families of victims of Ethiopian and Iranian air disasters will be able to get permanent residency
Iran did not defend itself in court to refute the plaintiff's evidence, making this a default judgment.
Belobaba said based on evidence from the plaintiffs and the balance of probabilities, the incident is considered a terrorist act under the State Immunity Act, the Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act and the Criminal Code.
The federal government plans to release its own forensic analysis with its own findings of fact about the tragedy which is expected expected to hold more weight, say legal experts.
WATCH | Friends and family carry wounds of Flight 752 a year later:
Friends and family carry wounds of Flight 752 a year later
7 months ago1:55
The Trudeau government has designated Jan. 8 a national day of remembrance for the victims of air disasters, including Flight 752. A year later, the plane crash in Iran haunts the loved ones left behind. 1:55
Lawyer plans to look internationally to seize assets
The suit's defendants include Iran, the country's armed forces, Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps and Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei.
The court decision is a way for victims' families in Canada to seek damages from Iran for the death of their loved ones.
Iran was served the claim in the fall of 2020 and was noted in default last December. The justice said the plaintiffs are entitled to default judgment on liability. Another court hearing will take place to determine compensation.
Litigation lawyer Mark Arnold is representing four families who lost children, nieces, spouses and nephews. The case was filed by Shahin Moghaddam, Mehrzad Zarei and Ali Gorji. Another plaintiff is unnamed over fear of reprisals from Iran.
Arnold told David Common, host of CBC News Network's Power & Politics, that there are Iranian assets in Canada and internationally that he would try to seize, including oil tankers.
"We will be looking internationally to seize whatever it is we can seize once we have a determination of what the level of compensation is," he said.
He also said his clients want justice and their day in court in front of an impartial judge.
But lawyer and human rights activist Kaveh Shahrooz said while today's ruling is welcome news for the families, the next challenge they will face is finding Iranian assets in Canada or enforcing the judgment in other jurisdictions.
"It is my hope that this decision does not prevent Canada's government from pursuing this case in international fora like the International Court of Justice," said Shahrooz. "And I hope such a court wouldn't view this case as a replacement for an international judgment that finds Iran responsible for the killing of 176 innocent people."
WATCH | UN official presses Iran for answers:
UN official presses Iran for answers on downed Ukrainian flight
5 months ago0:38
A report by UN special rapporteur Agnès Callamard says families who lost loved ones when Iran shot down Ukrainian International Airlines flight PS752 on Jan. 8, 2020, have not received the answers they deserve about why the plane was targeted. 0:38
Justice relied on 2 experts provided by plaintiff
Belobaba said he relied on two experts' reports filed by the plaintiffs to make the decision.
Dr. Bahman Jeldi, an Iranian analyst with the Canadian Center for Persian Studies, said the IRGC shot down the civilian plane with the intent to destroy it.
"Considering the TOR-M1 advanced military capabilities, two radars and control system, pre-approved flight plans and control of the airspace resting with the IRGC, and the firing of not one, but two missiles, it is not possible for two missiles to be fired by mistake as the IRGC claims," Jeldi said, as quoted in the decision. "There are multiple redundant systems and procedures to prevent accidental shooting of civilian aircraft."
Belobaba also said he relied on findings from Alireza Nader, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Defence of Democracies.
Flight PS752 shot down after being 'misidentified' as 'hostile target,' Iran's final report says
Canadian officials say Iran failed to prove Flight 752 was shot down in error
"It is highly unlikely that a technical 'misalignment' or 'human error' caused the IRGC operators to shoot down PS752," Nader said, as quoted in the judgment. The judge also pointed to findings from Agnès Callamard, the UN special rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, who conducted an investigation. The prime minister's former special advisor on Flight PS752, Ralph Goodale, and his report were also noted in the judge's decision. Canada entering into negotiations with Iran soon Conservative critic for foreign affairs, Michael Chong, said this court finding is "another confirmation that the IRGC should be listed as a terrorist entity by the Trudeau government, something it has refused to do." "Conservatives have been calling on the Trudeau government to stand up and help the victims and families of Flight 752 find closure and justice by listing the IRGC as a terrorist entity," he said in a statement. Foreign Affairs Minister Marc Garneau said last week Canada has identified the Quds Force, a branch of the IRGC, as a terrorist entity; however, victims' families say that's not enough because the Quds Force is not the Aerospace Force, the branch responsible for shooting down the plane. The Quds Force is in charge of operations outside Iran. In June 2018, the House of Commons passed a motion overwhelmingly calling on the federal government to make the change. The IRGC has not been listed as a terrorist entity since that vote. The lawyers involved in the private lawsuit were to hold a news conference Friday. WATCH | Lawyer Mark Arnold on seizing Iranian assets in Canada and internationally: Ontario court: Iran's shootdown of Flight PS752 was intentional and act of terrorism 2 months ago5:34 Lawyer Mark Arnold says once compensation for the families is determined, his team will look to seize Iranian assets in Canada and internationally. 5:34