Dear Wendy Nixon,
Director-General, Aviation Security Transport Canada
CC: Honorable Omar Alghabra, Minister of Transportation of Canada
CC; Honorable Marc Garneau, Minister Of Foreign Affair of Canada
First, thanks for your reply to my email such Quick. after two and half months!!!
As you know on may 20, justice Belobaba from Ontario Superior Court, based on facts and evidence plus Ms. Callamard and Ralph Goodale’s reports, ruled that shoot down PS752 was a premeditated terrorist act.
You as a non-governmental organization and an independent agency created by an Act of Parliament must admit the Canadian rules in the Judiciary system.
So DO NOT USE HUMAN ERROR AND NON-PREMEDITATIVE..
The forensic report is not true and is not based on fact and evidence. It is built by government pressure and dictating. The report by itself mentioned that it is not official and it can not be used in any court and judiciary systems so it's unacceptable how Canada published it as fact and an official report on the government website!!
Where is the detail of the TOR-M1 unit in the forensic report? The forensic team and TSB never had interviews and meeting with that kind of Missile system’s experts like Mr. Mike(Mihajlo) S. Mihajlovic. So Mr. Yaworsky can not tell me I don’t know how That Missile cockpit is a lookalike. it's unacceptable.
The name is clear it calls “FORENSIC”, so where are corps details and bodies residue pictures, information and Data’s, where are the DNA’s analysis, where are Toxicological tests result. this Forensic report has Obvious lots of Bridging. That reports Is came based on Iran’s report. Even there is nothing about TNT which was on the Iran report.
So DO NOT USE HUMAN ERROR AND NON-PREMEDITATIVE..
As you know I submitted a claim against Iran right about 20days after shoot dawn. It took 8month for This Liberal government to deliver the claim court order to Iran! You know why?! Because they didn’t want to.
I won the claim on May 20th, which you know the rules detail definitely. and I am waiting now for Judge to release his decision regards the Compensation and Fine amount. but still, Our government keeps Harassing my Lawyer. And pushing him to step back.
My Second Claim was submitted earlier this week against RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki, after consulting with some of the best Canadian Lawyers. You can easily find my claim by searching on the internet or you can go to my website in the forum section ( www.ps752memorial.com ). I assure you that I’m going to win this claim too, and she has two options only. One is to start a criminal investigation or resign.
I lost my wife and my son, there is nothing else to lose for me. therefore I have no hesitation toward justice and Vengeance. Whether how Canadian Government wants to deal and Negotiate with Iran. For me, it was clear that the Canadian government will do nothing after I saw Justin Trudeau in Javad Zarif's arms, laughed, and shook hands right 40 days after murdering 176 innocent people in the sky.
What the Canadian government did until now were Opaque, Duplicity and Deception. They just changed Mr. Champagne right after his interview with BBC which he said shoot down was preplanned and premeditative!
So DO NOT USE HUMAN ERROR AND NON-PREMEDITATIVE..
The TSB report and act in a matter of PS752 is so weird and questionable which is the third step I’m going to take toward Justice.
You wrote me about assurance, what are you and Your agency, TSB Canada, want to assure me about?
What are you going to do and what is your next step? I want to know your plan and your strategy against Iran in a matter of shoot down PS752?
How do you give me Justice when the TSB report is published based on nothing unless Iranian Dictates! why you didn’t report that site was Bulldozed and you didn’t have anything, any pieces of evidence to analyze.! Then you said Iran was so cooperative? How come?! What cooperation Iran did exactly?
You and Parliament published a very harsh statement regards the Belarus matter in 24 hours!, but nothing regards PS752. We are not Dumb, just be aware of that!
And again: DO NOT USE HUMAN ERROR AND NON-PREMEDITATIVE.
And please answer my question.
My Act is not related to the PS752 association, and they are not under my acceptance. Unfortunately, The Board of PS752 Association is so Weak and out of enough knowledge and necessary experience. They are So opinionated.
I just want to explain everything clearly. As I am well educated and grew up in a NAVAL family who are familiar with the plane/aerospace industry and military details, besides I read a lot about the TOR-M1 unit and personally discussed it with that Missile system expert.
I hope to see more concrete actions and transparent reports from TSB Canada, And all other Governmental or nongovernment organizations regard PS752.
It's clear which I don’t let the government, or any organization or any agencies, affect and stop me toward real Justice and transparency.
DO NOT USE HUMAN ERROR AND NON-PREMEDITATIVE..
Regards
Shahin Moghaddam
Aug26, 2021
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: O'Byrne, Tara On Behalf Of Nixon, Wendy To: mogadam@hotmail.com Subject: RE: PS752 consideration
Dear Shahin Moghaddam:
Thank you for your correspondence to the Minister of Transport regarding the Islamic Republic of Iran’s final accident investigation report into the downing of Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 (PS752). Please accept our apology for the delay in replying.
Transport Canada is committed to seeking justice for the families of the victims of PS752, and to pursuing accountability from the Iranian Government. It is clear that Canada is not satisfied with Iran’s explanation to date, and we remain committed in our pursuit of answers. Iran’s Final report, which cited missile damage to PS752 as the primary cause of its downing, with human error presented as a contributing factor, does not provide answers. It details what happened, but does not address why it happened.
In order to hold Iran accountable and seek justice for the victims and their families, a more complete analysis of the causes and contributing factors that led to the downing of PS752 was undertaken by Canada’s Forensic Examination and Assessment Team, which has been collecting, organizing, analyzing, and challenging all available sources of information related to the PS752 disaster. The Team has been provided the details you referred to in your correspondence, and has closely examined the decisions and omissions made by the Iranian authorities that led to the downing of PS752, as well as Iran’s final report.
As you may be aware, the Team released its report on June 24, 2021. The report contains a series of facts that highlight how Iranian civilian and military authorities, through their decisions, actions, and omissions, played a significant role in the downing of Flight PS752. The report clearly demonstrates that, although human error did play a key role in the incident, senior regime officials made decisions that directly led to this tragedy. However, Canada found no evidence that the downing was premeditated. Massive failures in communication between the unit and the command and control are at the heart of this tragedy.
The report also emphasizes Iran’s troubling lack of transparency. Indeed, its official account of events is dishonest, misleading, and superficial. It deliberately ignores key factors and does not provide answers as to why Iran did not put measures in place to prevent this tragedy.
In closing, please be assured that this issue remains one of the department’s top priorities. We will continue this work, even during these challenging times, until our questions have been answered.
Again, thank you for writing and sharing your comments.
Sincerely,
Wendy Nixon
Director General, Aviation Security
Transport Canada
Subject: Re: PS752 – Demand for Factual Integrity and Government Accountability
Dear Ms. Nixon,
Thank you for your response.
However, I must express my deep disappointment with the content of your reply. Once again, it repeats the misleading narrative of “human error” and “non-premeditated” action—terms that not only contradict the evidence but also diminish the truth and insult the victims’ families, including myself.
Let me be absolutely clear: on May 20, 2021, Justice Edward Belobaba of the Ontario Superior Court ruled that the downing of Flight PS752 was a deliberate act of terrorism, based on detailed evidence, expert testimony, and credible reports, including those by Ms. Agnès Callamard and Mr. Ralph Goodale. In a democratic country like Canada, it is expected that government agencies—whether governmental or arm’s-length—respect and follow the findings of the judicial system.
Therefore, I demand that Transport Canada and all associated departments and agencies immediately cease using the false terms “human error” and “non-premeditated.”
Moreover, the so-called “forensic report” your department references is not a reliable or legally valid document. It explicitly states that it cannot be used in court, and it lacks transparency, scientific rigor, and essential forensic elements. Where are the toxicological reports, DNA records, and detailed analyses of bodily remains? Where is the reconstruction of the missile impact and warhead detonation pattern? How can a report labeled “forensic” omit these critical components?
Most importantly, the report completely fails to consult with actual experts on the TOR-M1 missile system, such as Mr. Mihajlo S. Mihajlovic, who is internationally recognized for his expertise in this field. Without expert analysis of the system that was used to destroy the plane, the conclusions drawn by this report lack any technical credibility.
In addition to these deficiencies, I must emphasize a crucial point: the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) is a civilian investigative agency designed to analyze incidents like engine failures, mechanical breakdowns, pilot misjudgments, or other safety issues unrelated to military activity. It may have expertise in explaining why a plane’s engine caught fire or why landing gear malfunctioned—but not why a military-grade surface-to-air missile system launched two warheads at a civilian aircraft.
The TSB is neither legally mandated nor technically equipped to assess:
Surface-to-air missile behavior,
Military command structures,
Radar locking protocols,
Or the use of force under rules of engagement in a military setting.
This was not an aviation safety accident. It was a military strike. A war crime. A state-sponsored terrorist act.
Delegating the investigation of such a matter to a transportation board—while ignoring military analysts, weapons experts, and criminal investigators—reveals either gross negligence or deliberate misdirection. It is unacceptable and must be publicly corrected.
You state that Canada is not satisfied with Iran’s explanations. Yet, what concrete action has been taken to challenge them? The forensic report’s vague conclusions echo the Iranian regime’s propaganda far more than they represent a search for truth.
Let us not forget: Iran bulldozed the crash site. It denied investigators access. It harassed victims’ families. It lied repeatedly about the incident. Yet somehow, Canada continues to describe its actions as “cooperation”? On what grounds?
We submitted a legal claim against Iran less than 20 days after the incident. It took eight months for the Liberal government to deliver the claim to Iran—delays that were not accidental, but deliberate. We won that case on May 20, and now await the court’s decision on compensation and damages. Despite this, my legal counsel continues to face obstruction from Canadian authorities.
I submitted a claim—this time against RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki, for failing to open a criminal investigation. This claim is publicly accessible, including on my website (www.ps752memorial.com). Waiting for NSIRAto answer.
I have already lost my wife and my son. I have nothing else to lose—only justice to pursue. And I will pursue it relentlessly.
The moment I saw Prime Minister Justin Trudeau smiling and shaking hands with Javad Zarif in Munich, just 40 days after the murder of 176 innocent people, I knew that Canada would do nothing. Since then, every action this government has taken regarding PS752 has been marked by opacity, duplicity, and deception—from the forced replacement of Foreign Minister Champagne after he told the BBC the downing was "premeditated," to the continued defense of an indefensible forensic narrative.
You mention “assurance.” But what exactly are you assuring me of? What steps are you and your department taking now? What is your strategy to hold Iran accountable? What is your timeline for justice? How will you revise the forensic findings based on the court's ruling? Where is the plan?
As a final note, I would like to clarify: I act independently of the PS752 Association. I do not endorse its leadership, which I find to be uninformed, politically compromised, and lacking the necessary expertise to represent the victims' cause effectively.
I was raised in a naval family, well-versed in aerospace and defense systems. I have personally studied the TOR-M1 system in depth, and spoken to experts. I will not allow technical falsehoods, political convenience, or bureaucratic language to bury the truth.
Stop using the terms “human error” and “non-premeditated.” They are false. They are harmful. And they will not be accepted.
I expect a clear, honest response to the questions raised above—not another templated reply.
Sincerely,
Shahin Moghaddam
June 2025
Education is evolving, and UNICCM is leading the way in online learning. Their courses are well-crafted, affordable, and backed by professional support. Whether you’re reskilling or upskilling, make UNICCM your partner in growth.
Enhance your database management expertise with MySQL Training in Pune at WebAsha Technologies. Our comprehensive course covers database design, queries, optimization, and real-world applications. Learn from industry experts through hands-on projects and practical training. Enroll today to gain in-demand skills and excel in the world of databases!